Margarita Lacabe

Jun 082011
 

When Mayor Stephen Cassidy announced last March that the city would not be hiring a search firm to look for a new City Manager, I was not the only one to speculate that the Mayor had someone in mind for the job.   Generally these types of low-intensity searches are only conducted when a viable internal candidate has already been identified, but none of the likely candidates in San Leandro had expressed any interest in the job.  The manner in which the “search” was conducted  – in secrecy, with no community input to speak of and with the search committee keeping completely mum about the candidates – further strengthened these suspicions.  Add to this the rumors that a well-known local business lobbyist with ties to Cassidy had been approaching City Council members praising the virtues of the City Manager of a nearby town, and it’s not hard to add 2 and 2 together.  Cassidy had his man for the job – and he seemed willing to railroad the City Council into accepting him.

Cassidy’s candidate did not look bad on paper – he had ties to San Leandro and had done a reasonably OK job of managing the prosperous, predominantly white city he’d been in charge of for six years.  He had come into some recent troubles, over the issue of employee pension contributions no less, but Cassidy would probably see that as a plus.  In any case, for reasons unknown, he withdrew his application before it could be considered by the full Council.

The City Council was left to interview 4 or 5 other candidates.   By all accounts they were a diverse group, though not necessarily a competent one.  The low key search, and the likely presumption among potential candidates that the results were predetermined, had not encouraged top-CM candidates to submit their applications.   Cassidy still had a favorite among this group – the young city manager of a nearby city with a population one-fourth the size of San Leandro’s and a median household income twice as high as our own.  Managing a city with a population less than 6% Latino and 1% black, it’s no wonder that he fumbled the “diversity” question and left several City Council members unimpressed.  But Cassidy wanted him and fought for him until finally accepting last night that he would not get his way.

So the City Council is back to square one: needing to find a City Manager.  This time they are ready to do it right: hire a search firm, which will make a broad, hopefully nation-wide search, and recruit candidates with experience running cities with diverse populations and changing economic structures.  San Leandro has much to offer to the right candidate: we are a pleasant town, with a wonderful weather, relatively low-crime and a cohesive, if diverse, population.  Our problems: fixing our schools, establishing a long-term balanced budget and enhancing the standard of living of residents, are tough but not insurmountable.  This is the sort of town where someone with a modicum of competence and inspiration can make a name for herself.  We just need to find the right person, it looks like we’re finally looking.

Jun 022011
 

The California Citizens Redistricting Commission is hard at work drawing new lines for California Assembly and Senate districts as well as federal congressional districts, and things are not looking good for San Leandro.  While the only maps published so far are just preliminary projections, they split San Leandro pretty much down the middle.  Much of the northern part of town will join Oakland in the Assembly and congressional districts (good for Barbara Lee fans!) and the other part will stay with Hayward and Union City (that, if I’m reading the maps right, you can see the proposed Assembly map and proposed Congressional map for yourself). Stark and McNerney will end up in the same district, which may not be a bad thing as Stark is pushing 80 and probably ready to retire.  Alas, it would do away with Corbett’s and Hayashi’s congressional ambitions.

In practical terms, this means that San Leandro will pretty much lose any of the political weight it has had as a city.  The divided city will offer too few votes for any of its representatives in the Legislature or Congress to be concerned about any particular San Leandro issues.  Local politicians will also have a very hard time rising to the state or national stage as they won’t be able to count with the backing of all their local constituents.  Historically, San Leandro politicians have done well outside the city.  Both the current California Senate Majority leader, Ellen Corbett,  and the State Treasurer (and former Attorney General) Bill Lockyer are from San Leandro (though Lockyer currently lives in Hayward, he started his political career in the San Leandro School Board).   I suspect that this has been in part because San Leandro is, all in all, pretty cohesive as a community.  It enjoys a local newspaper read by everyone in town and has a relatively active civic life.  I suspect that San Leandro voters vote for San Leandro politicians much more often than voters outside our borders.  In the last elections for the Alameda County Democratic Central Committee, 18th district, 13 candidates run for 6 seats.  Five of the candidates elected to those 6 seats were from San Leandro, only one San Leandro candidate did not get chosen (but she was close).  I suspect that this will no longer be the case after the split.

The map is still preliminary, and the Commission will accept public input until it issues its final maps in August.  I’ve heard that they are very interested in hearing from the public, and they do want to keep cities and communities of interest together.  If you feel, like I, that San Leandro is not just a city but a community and that it should be kept whole, please contact the commission and let them know.  Every voice will count.  You can e-mail them using this form.

May 312011
 

The demographics of San Leandro have changed dramatically in the last few years.  According to the 2011 census, just 27% of San Leandrans identify themselves as white, down from 51% in 2000.  In 1970, however, a full 97% of San Leandrans were white.  Africans American today make up almost 12% of the population; in 1970 they were 0.1%.  Those numbers were not happenstance, rather, they were the result of very specific and very successful policies of racial discrimination that kept non-whites, and in particular blacks, from moving into the city.   Originally, non-whites were kept out of town by restrictive covenants.  Once these were ruled unconstitutional, elected officials, the Chamber of Commerce, homeowner associations, apartment owners and realtors all conspired to prevent blacks from renting or buying property in town.  Realtors would not show houses to blacks, owners would not sell them, and anyone who refused to tow the line would feel the pressure from the rest.  Only in the late ’80s did San Leandro start to integrate.

San Leandro’s dirty history as one of the most racist town in America was definitely known to African Americans in nearby communities.  It became known to the rest of the country due to a couple of TV news stories (The Suburban Wall and the Invisible Wall) that showcased the problem.  But as time went on, and new people came to town, San Leandro’s racial history seemed to be forgotten.  It wasn’t until comedian Brian Copeland started his one-man-show “Not A Genuine Black Man”, which deals, in part, about perils he suffered as a black boy who moved into San Leandro in the 70’s, that the issue came back to light.  But not everyone was happy with that.

In 2005, City Manager John Jermanis and Public Library Director David Bohne decided to commission a book on the history of San Leandro.  They hired a young writer to do this, he produced an outline that included a chapter on this unpleasant aspect of San Leandro history.  The writer also proposed to talk to Brian Copeland about his own experiences.  Jermanis and Bohne ordered him to leave that part out of the book; when he refused on ethical grounds, they cancelled the whole book project.   Of course, they did that as quietly as possible.

I found out about the botched history book through an e-mail by Brian Copeland that a friend forwarded.  I set out to find out what had actually happened, and contacted Jermanis, Bohne and several city council members.  Jermanis originally talked to me, but when he realized that he couldn’t make his actions look in any way legitimate, he quickly stopped the conversation.  Bohne, meanwhile, made excuses for months to not accept my calls.  When I finally met him at a public event, he refused to even speak to me.  Jermanis, meanwhile, ordered the then public information officer Jane Crea to come up with a “story” to justify what they had done.  Unfortunately, her story had many holes and contradicted other facts.  What I learned from all of this, was that the racist policies that had driven this city until the 1980’s were alive and well at City Hall and at the Public Library.

I documented some of my conversations at the time on a webpage that I shared my friends and colleagues.  I’m sharing it with the public now because history – even history about the desire to censor history – needs to be known.

Jermanis retired a few years ago as City Manager, but Bohne continues to head the library.  Neither the City Council nor the Library Commission ever held either of them into account for their attempts to censor San Leandro history.

May 292011
 

The Black History 101 Mobile Museum is coming to San Leandro on June 4th for a 1-day-only Taste of Freedom event at the Linen Life Gallery.  The Museum travels around the country and features exhibits that highlight the historical experience of African-Americans, from the slave era to hip-hop culture.  This particular event will be commemorating Malcom X, and will feature a lecture by Professor Griff, a rapper with the group Public Enemy.

Tickets for the event start at $30, and include an all-you-can-eat taster, access to the exhibit, lecture and entertainment.  You can buy them online or at the venue. The event is for adults 21 and older.

I find it very fitting that this event will take place in San Leandro – a city that does not have a black history of its own, as African-Americans were not allowed to live within the cities until the 1980s.  Before that, both restrictive covenants and a conspiracy of homeowner associations, realtors and local politicians kept African Americans from buying property in town.  In the late 1960’s, the US Commission on Civil Rights held hearings on housing discrimination in San Leandro but they did little to solve the problem.  By 1971, Sa Leandro was known as the “most racist town in America” and its discriminatory practices were the subject of  The Suburban Wall, a TV documentary, which features San Leandro Mayor Maltester explaining how blacks don’t want to live in San Leandro because this is a boring town.  Anyone interested in this period of history should read Brian Copeland’s amazing memoir Not a Genuine Black Man: Or, How I Claimed My Piece of Ground in the Lily-White Suburbs.

May 272011
 

The Education Trust West, a California educational advocacy organization, has just released  A Report on District Achievement: How Low-income, African-American, and Latino Students Fare in California School Districts and it has few good things to say about the San Leandro Unified School District (SLUSD).  The report looks at how the 146 largest school districts in California are serving their African American and Latino students, focusing on student performance and improvement, the achievement gap between students of different races and the college readiness of the target population.  San Leandro comes at the very bottom of the list; it’s the lowest ranked district in Alameda County and the 140th worst of the 146 districts in the study.  Its worst score (an F) is for the achievement gap between white and black students.

This study looked at data collected in 2010, and focuses on the improvements done since 2005.  During that time period, SLUSD was ran by former Superintendent Christine Lim.  Lim had made reducing the achievement gap the focus of her mandate.   She seemed convinced that the low scores of “black and brown” students were due to racist teachers not understanding their students.  To address the problem, she introduced diversity teaching training and lax discipline policies for students of color, which contributed to an increase of classroom disruptions and a growing antagonism between the teaching staff and the administration.  In 2008, San Leandro Teachers Association took a no-confidence vote against Lim, which passed with 90% of the vote. Lim was finally fired in December 2009, for undisclosed reasons.  It would seem, that her measures to reduce the achievement gap not only had the effect of embittering teachers, but of actually increasing it.

Looking at the achievement statistics between different racial/ethnic groups in San Leandro is a sobering experience.  Asians do significantly better than all other groups.  At San Leandro High School, for example, Asians’ API is 90 point higher than whites’ (which in turn is about 120 points higher than that of blacks’ and Latinos’).  As you would expect (given stereotypes, if nothing else), Asians do significantly better than all other racial group in math, 44% of them scored “advanced” in the HS exit exam, vs. 17% whites, 7% of Latinos and 3% of blacks.  But they also do better in English: 59% of Asians scored “advanced” in English in the same exam, versus 43% whites, 16% Latinos and 17% of blacks.  Filipinos , meanwhile, throw a wrench into any sense we want to make with these numbers.  Their API scores are only slightly lower than whites’, but they do almost as badly as Latinos in the HS exit exam.  However, they were the only subgroup who had 100% graduation rate in 2010.

Now, everyone agrees that the causes of the achievement gap are many and complex, ranging from family and cultural background, early learning opportunities to institutionalized racism at public schools.  I definitely don’t dismiss the latter.  I came to America when I was 14 with an elementary grasp of English, and was immediately stereotyped as being uneducated and dumb.  My counselor pushed me to take cooking and typing, when I wanted to take academic classes; he enrolled me in basic math, and I had to fight to get transferred to Calculus.  High School, for me, was a struggle against low expectations.  Fortunately by 14 I had a very good sense of self and was willing to fight for myself (and I come from a national culture that believes in fighting, something that is not universally true in Latin America), but I shouldn’t have had to.  Thus I believe any training that makes teachers and counselors check themselves for negative stereotypes of students is likely to be helpful, but it’s not enough.   Districts that do well, for example, are quick to identify students with problems and to give them specialized help – something that SLUSD started doing last year.  But helping all black and Latino students do significantly better is, I believe, something that the school district cannot do on its own.  It’s time it got the community involved.

What I propose is that the School District start with a series of meetings between parents and teachers, where both groups can honestly speak to each other about what goes on within the classroom and outside of it.   For example, I would like to see a meeting for Spanish-speaking parents, conducted in Spanish, where these parents could be asked what are the challenges that they find in educating their kids, what are the obstacles that the school puts in their paths, and what they want to see from the school district – or the city as a whole.  For example, we complain about parents not reading to their children but Spanish speaking parents most often don’t have access to Spanish language children’s books.  While these are available at public libraries, parents don’t necessarily know how these function and how to use them.  Perhaps something as simple as Spanish-speaking library parent training could have significant impacts on how much children are read to.  Another challenge for Spanish speaking parents is helping their children learn to read – many of us just cannot pronounce the proper vowel sounds in English. Perhaps we could create a program of older elementary school or middle school kids helping kindergardeners sound out words and thus open up reading for them that much earlier.

The possibilities of programs that could make small but aggregate differences for student learning is enormous, but in order to identify problems and solutions we need to talk to one another.  So far, the School District has not been talking to parents. Let’s hope that changes soon.