Margarita Lacabe

Nov 052011
 

Mary Hayashi accused of shoplifting $2K worth of clothing at Neiman Marcus, but would it have been better if she’d bought it?

Assemblywoman Mary Hayashi

The Bay Area political world was in full giggle mode last week, as the San Francisco Chronicle reported that Mary Hayashi, who represents San Leandro at the California Assembly had been arrested for shoplifting.  Hayashi is a pretty controversial figure in Bay Area political circles, a powerful campaigner and even more successful fundraiser, she’s known both for talking the talk of her labor and Democratic supporters and walking the walk of her big donors.  She does dress well, though, and she is probably one of very few politicians who, at 45 years of age, can get away with wearing $1250 designer black leather leggings.

The question of whether Mary Hayashi actually meant to shoplift those leggings (plus a skirt and a blouse) is for the court to decide.  What I am posing here is a more significant moral question.  Is it a worse deed to shoplift $2445 worth of clothing from Neiman Marcus or to buy $2445 worth of clothing at Neiman Marcus? I mean, really, in this economy, when many people are doing their clothing shopping at the thrift store, can a Democratic politician really justify spending that much money on three items of clothing?  That’s enough to pay some people’s mortgages for at least a couple of months!

So, my dear readers, what do you think?

[poll id=”6″]

 

 

Nov 022011
 

Former SLPD officer DeWayne Stancill

Read the legal documents on the allegations of racial and sexual harassment and the SLPD.

(This post has been revised and re-revised since its original publication).

In early 2008, a number of female police officers at the San Leandro Police Department made internal complaints regarding sexual harassment by then sergeant DeWayne Stancill.  The city responded by promptly hiring an outside investigator to look into the complaints.  The report concluded that the complaints were unfounded, but that Stancill’s behavior had at times been inappropriate.  A second investigation prompted by reports of sexual harassment and retaliation made by Officer Debra Trujillo against Stancill, also cleared him of wrongdoing.   Stancill then filed his own complaint of racial harassment, naming the officers who previously complained against him as well as others associated with them.  The City hired a private attorney to investigate the matter, who concluded that some officers had made derogatory remarks against Stancill, but it wasn’t because of his race.

Stancill was later demoted from Sergeant and then fired for allegedly unrelated reasons.

The female officers sued for sexual harassment and discrimination, and the City settled for various amounts, from $25K to $295K.   The City also agreed to institute changes in the police department, including changes to how promotions are given.    In the case of Officer Trujillo, the City did not settle, went to trial and won.  Stancill sued the City for wrongful termination, the City recently settled that lawsuit for over $300K, including attorney’s fees. He was reinstated to his job, from which he then retired.

Recently, the East Bay Express published an article on the controversy written by San Leandro blogger Steven Tavares.  Tavares is not particularly well known for his journalistic standards, and he mostly tells Stancill’s side of the story, but it’s a story that has not been told before.  Given the gravity of the story, and its cost to the city, I think it’s a story that has to be told carefully.

At this point, having read only the private investigation reports, I have more questions than answers: Why did the City spend over $1M settling cases that its investigators have deemed baseless? If the city was concerned with the cost/risk of litigation, why did it not settle the case brought by Officer Trujillo? What were the real basis of animosity towards Stancill in the department?  Why was he really fired?  Is the fact that Stancill’s 19yo son, a gang member, shot and killed a SLHS student during this period, unrelated to how other officers reacted towards him? And is the tendentious nature of the report on Stancill’s allegations a result of the investigator’s ineptitude or a sign of what the City Attorney wanted the “official story” to be?

I hope to find some answers as I read more of the court documents.  I will post those documents I find relevant here. I will be posting the City’s private investigators’ reports on the sexual and racial harassment allegations.  These reports should not have been made public, as they convey private information about police officers and opinions presented by them in what they thought was a confidential setting.  However, the reports were made public when introduced into the court proceedings and are available for download from the court’s website.  I am posting them here for ease of access, but I’m redacting names of people who refused to make official complains, as well as others who did not have a chance to defend themselves.  I am also redacting personal information that is irrelevant to the case.

Report on the Investigation of Sexual Harassment complaints
This report was made by private investigator Debra L. Estrin, who was hired by the law firm that represents the city, Meyers Nave, to investigate the claims made by female police officers of sexual harassment by DeWayne Stancill.  In my opinion, it’s a well researched and professionally written report.

Report on the Investigation of Stancill’s allegations of racial harassment
This report was made by private attorney Patricia Elliot, hired by Meyers Nave to investigate allegations of racial harassment made by DeWayne Stancill.  This report is sloppily written, with multiple factual mistakes, selectively quotes parts of the Estrin report, ignoring the context, and comes to conclusions unsupported by the evidence presented.  Whether that’s because of incompetence by the investigator, personal bias or direction by Meyers Nave is unclear.

City’s Motion for Summary Judgement
On the case brought by Stancill for wrongful termination.  It explains the city’s reasons for terminating Stancil: that he acted unprofessionally by wearing a teaching saying “Acquitted,” after the report on the sexual harassment complaints (see above) came out, by not recusing himself from doing the background check on an applicant which he knew (he told his supervisor her knew the applicant, but not that he had previously recommended him for another job), and by not telling a sergeant that he believed the father of an injured suspect was a dangerous “crook”, when said sergeant suggested he let said father see his son in the hospital.  The motion was denied.

Oct 092011
 

What is the San Leandro city government up to?   Often times I wonder myself, but without a local press that digs into its deeds (and misdeeds), we generally have no idea. I think we should change that!  If the press won’t keep an eye on local government, let’s do it ourselves!

What I propose is simple: let’s have members of the community volunteer to attend key public meetings and update the rest of the San Leandro community as to what was discussed at those meetings.  It sounds boring, but it might actually be pretty significant.  For example, at the last Business & Housing Development Committee meetings one of the issues discussed was “updating” the Zoning code to make regulations of “entertainment and assembly” uses uniform throughout the industrial area.  Now, by reading the very abbreviated minutes I have no idea what that means – but I bet it’s something related to the Faith Fellowship lawsuit, and something that could be of big consequences for the city (by either subjecting us to more lawsuits, or taking away valuable property rights).   Whatever it is, it is something I bet City staff will try to sneak in.  It’d be great if someone could make sure they don’t.

What I envision, are community volunteers (that means YOU!) choosing a committee or commission to follow (prioritizing the most important ones first), then taking a look at that committee’s/commission’s agenda, digging deeper into potentially interesting items and attending meetings when interesting things may be discussed.  Then, they can write about it (on this blog, on the Patch, on their own blog, wherever) so as to keep the whole community updated. BTW, no reason why this couldn’t/shouldn’t be done for School Board committees as well.

If you’re more of the stay-at-home type, then how about picking a topic and following it up through California Public Records Acts requests? San Leandro Bytes has done several of these type of stories before, and I’m sure Mike could give you some guidance on how to go about it.

Some come on! Join me on keeping an eye on our elected (and non-elected!) officials. If you’re interested in helping with this project, please e-mail me!

Oct 042011
 

Today (Oct. 3, 2011), the US Supreme Court denied certiorari on the City of San Leandro vs. Faith Fellowship case.  As it is its practice, the Supreme Court did not provide a reason for this denial.  What this means is that if this case it’s not settled, it will go on to trial.  The jury will then have to decide basically whether the Church could have acquired another property in a residential-zoned area of San Leandro that would have suited their purposes.  Former city manager Jermanis said in his deposition that it couldn’t.  In my opinion, it’s quite likely that the Church would win.

The question now is one of damages.  How much would the Church be awarded if it went to trial, and how much should the city offer to settle for so as to avoid going to trial.   Previous statements by the Church, suggest that they’ll be asking for as much as $3.7 million in damages, the $1.2 million they paid in mortgage payments while the owned, but could not occupy the Catalina St. property, and the $2 million they lost when they finally had to sell it.  To that we should add the Church’s attorney fees, which could be in the hundreds of thousands of dollars (the City of San Leandro itself has spent about $600,000 on this lawsuit).

The city has an ace up its sleeve, however.  Quoting from a previous post: “it is not clear that RLUIPA [the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, under which this case is being fought]  allows for money damages.  While some courts have found that it does, following the Supreme Court’s reasoning in Franklin v. Gwinett, the US Supreme Court just ruled in Sossamon v. Texas (a case involving prisoners’ religious rights) that  the phrase “‘[a]ppropriate relief’ is open-ended and ambiguous about what types of relief it includes” and that, at least in the case of lawsuits against states (which, unlike municipalities, enjoy sovereign immunity) it should not be interpreted to include monetary damages.  Now, because the Sossamon court ruled on very specific circumstances, it’s not clear how lower courts will interpret the decision.  They may very well conclude that it would be inconsistent to read RLUIPA’s grant of “appropriate relief” to include monetary damages when the state actor is a municipality or county, but to not include them when the actor is a state.  Or they may decide that the fact that Supreme Court specifically differentiated Sossamon from Franklin means that Franklin applies to non-sovereign RLUIPA defendants.”

This means that while the city has almost certainly lost the case, the matter of how much – if anything – it will have to pay Faith Fellowship is still in the air.  The city could chose to try its chances at a trial and, if it loses (as it’s likely), fight the question of monetary damages.  It once again can go up the appellate ladder all the way to the US Supreme Court.   This would certainly please Meyers Nave, the city’s law firm, which has raked in millions of dollars out of the bad advise it’s given the city.  Another series of trials and appeals could mean hundreds of thousands of dollars more in their pockets.

The realistic threat of further litigation, which would mean not getting a final settlement for several more years, if at all, might make Faith Fellowship more willing to settle for a reasonable sum.  Of course, pursuing settlement options would have been a better choice back in February before the 9th circuit and the Supreme Court said “no”  to the City, now Faith Fellowship has much less to lose.  But money with which they could buy a new property now is better than money a few years from now.

Whether the city decides to settle or go to trial, I can only hope they will finally do the smart thing and hire a /new/ law firm to represent them.  Meyers Nave terrible advise on this case will most likely end up costing the city millions of dollars, and truth be told, we cannot afford to keep taking their advise.

Previous Posts on this subject

San Leandro gears up for Constitutional fight (May 2011)

The Faith Fellowship lawsuit: it’s time for the city of San Leandro to settle (April 2011)

A primer on the Faith Fellowship v. San Leandro lawsuit (April 2011)

A look at San Leandro’s City Attorney: Time to fire Meyers Nave?

Sep 262011
 

The San Leandro Rotary Club has been a long time supporter of our local high school students granting college scholarships and scholarships to RYLA Leadership Camp.  The “Lobsters for Literacy” Lobster Feed sustains these scholarships as well as funds the now 6th annual distribution of dictionaries to all 3rd grade students in the San Leandro School District.

This year, the Lobsters for Literacy event will be held on Friday, October 7, 2011 at the Boys & Girls Club (401 Marina Blvd).  Tickets are running out!  So we ask that anyone in San Leandro and the surrounding area who is interested in attending and supporting the local educational system to order tickets before it is too late.

Tickets are $75 each for Maine Lobsters or alternatively, Prime Rib.  Dinner includes salad, pasta & garlic bread catered by Miraglia Catering, one of the best catering venues in the Bay Area, and based right here in San Leandro.  There will also be a No-Host Bar for wine, beer, cocktails & soft drinks.

For some fun, attendees will get a chance to win raffle prizes. Raffle tickets will be sold at the venue.  Grand prizes will include an iPad and a large-screen television.  There will be many more fun items for raffle as well.

For more information, please contact Dr. Rosalia Saavedra at 510.381.5207 or email her at drsaavedra@sloginc.com, or contact Lisa McClure at 510.347.4620 ext. 101.  Her email is lmccclure@davisstreet.org.

You can buy tickets online at http://sanleandrorotary.org/